Welcome to Paradise. Set on two lush acres along one of Middletown’s most coveted roads, Paradise Found is a home with unmistakable personality; an artful, design-forward retreat where historic character, vibrant interiors and resort-style living come together in a truly memorable setting. Accessed via scenic Bailey Avenue and bordered in part by an original stone wall, the property feels wonderfully private while remaining accessible, just minutes from Second and Third Beaches, Sachuest Point and the Norman Bird Sanctuary.

Originally built in 1920, the residence has been lovingly and thoughtfully reimagined over the years with an eclectic point of view, an appreciation for craftsmanship and absolutely no fear of color. Throughout the home, bold wallpapers, custom millwork, unexpected details and distinctive lighting create spaces that feel collected rather than decorated.

The tone is set in the mudroom, where terrazzo floors, detailed molding and handsome built-in storage make an everyday entrance feel special. From there, the home unfolds into a series of bright, expressive living spaces. The vibrant main living room features a vaulted, beamed ceiling and colorful Schumacher wallpaper, while a more formal front sitting room is framed by a wide cased opening and an abundance of windows. A separate office and additional den/family room provide flexible places to work, gather or unwind, with views extending across the surrounding grounds. Even the space beneath the stairs has been cleverly transformed into a whimsical children’s hideaway and extra storage.

At the heart of the home, the kitchen pairs warmth and function with a playful sense of style, featuring wood cabinetry, a generous center island and colorful accents. An adjoining butler’s pantry continues the theme with glass-front cabinetry and statement Makelike wallpaper, creating a practical transition space with just as much character as the rooms around it.

Upstairs, the bedrooms are equally individual. One spacious room features vaulted ceilings and custom built-in bunks, while another ensuite bedroom includes its own sitting area and a cheerful bath. A distinctive hall bath is designed around a four-spigot trough sink and classic tilework, and a conveniently located laundry room completes the hallway. The expansive primary suite offers a more serene retreat, with a large marble-tiled bath, freestanding tub, generous dressing room, ample closet spaces, and a charming sitting room capped by a wood-paneled turret ceiling.

The outdoor spaces are every bit as considered. A raised deck off the main house includes an outdoor shower and overlooks the private grounds, but the property truly begins to live like a compound beyond the main residence.

A separate pool house offers approximately 1,491 additional square feet of space, including an exercise room, two-car garage and beautifully finished guest quarters above. The upper level opens into a vaulted kitchen, dining and living area brought to life by wall murals painted by local artist Chris Willey. The bright kitchen features a center island and Smeg appliances, while a full bath with colorful custom tile and a spacious bedroom make the space ideal for extended stays, guests or summer entertaining. An elevated deck overlooks the pool and patio below.

At the center of the backyard is an in-ground saltwater pool and hot tub surrounded by thoughtfully landscaped gardens and generous areas for gathering. A hardscaped patio with a pergola creates an inviting setting for outdoor dining, while a covered cabana offers a shaded place to lounge throughout the warmer months. A separate garage structure with loft storage adds even more flexibility to the property.
Playful yet sophisticated, historic yet completely individual, 80 Paradise Avenue is the kind of home that could only have evolved over time. With its bold, design-forward interiors, beautifully created guest house, luxurious pool and expansive grounds, every corner offers something unexpected.